When our kids were smaller and our budget was also smaller. The All-Star Resorts were always our first choice of locations to stay on the Disney properties. This is an ideal location if you have younger children with so much for them to see and very large pools. This met many if not all our needs at the time but, as we all grew older our priorities changed. The pluses for the All-Star resorts are prices and lots of excitement and lastly the food court did serve its purpose. One of my biggest complaints would be the buses always very crowed even though they did seem to run more often than other properties on site.
When picking any of these we have found them all to be equal it would just be your preference for the theme you wish to visit.